Category: 1930s

Naughty Marietta (1935)

Jeannette MacDonald is certainly a talented singer, but her voice isn’t of a type that appeals to me. In this film, she’s a European princess who, in order to avoid an arranged marriage, flees on a ship of casquette girls to America. There she meets pirates, gypsies, and a mercenary played by Nelson Eddy whom she falls in love with. The majority of the story is rather yawn-worthy and the songs just feel thrown in to show off MacDonald and Eddy’s voices, offering little flow with the story itself.  Best Picture Nomination

Oscar Winner: Best Sound, Recording

Oscar Nomination: Best Picture

The Lost Patrol (1934)

A lost British Army patrol, counting Boris Karloff and Victor McLaglen amongst its members, is stranded in an oasis in the Cradle of Civilization; their last orders lost in the mind of a now-deceased officer. They are surrounded by the enemy with little chance of survival. The tension is strong and it’s a dark, psychological battle for each of the soldiers, where few if any will survive. I do enjoy the story telling in this era of John Ford films (fairly short run times with compelling stories told in tight locales) over his sweeping westerns.  War

Oscar Nomination: Best Music, Score

Jewel Robbery (1932)

This offers the best of Pre-Code films: philandering, drug use, and ‘bad’ people not getting their comeuppance. William Powell is a gentleman robber who catches the already wandering eye of rich and married Kay Francis. She is beautiful, he is oozing charisma, and together they have wonderful chemistry. There’s not much to the story, but it doesn’t overstay its rather short runtime.

Lawyer Man (1932)

Portraying the meteoric rise and fall of a New York attorney, Lawyer Man has a threadbare story and is really a waste of the talents of William Powell and Joan Blondell. Powell is the titular lawyer. His charisma is present as always but he’s just going through the motions that has him beginning and ending at the same exact place. Blondell is his long-suffering, but loyal secretary who follows him on his journey to nowhere.

Man Wanted (1932)

Kay Francis is a hard-working magazine editor who falls in love with her new secretary, played by David Manners. Unfortunately she is married to a philandering playboy and Manners is engaged to Una Merkel. While not a terrible film, the plot is as thin as that and goes in all the expected directions as the two navigate their attraction to each other.

They Call It Sin (1932)

Traveling salesman David Manners sweeps church organist Loretta Young off her feet when he visits her small town. After her adoptive parents chase her away with accusations of being the wrong type of woman, she follows Manners to New York where she discovers he is already engaged. George Brent completes the love triangle while Una Merkel fills in as the sassy best friend who shows her the ropes in the big city. The shoestring plot, which includes a hokey last-minute exonerating medical procedure, is all held up with Young’s acting. She manages to convey the whole range of emotions as a small town girl dealing with the highs and lows of young love and navigating the alien, big city filled with villains willing to take advantage of every angle.

Dark Victory (1939)

Bette Davis, as a flighty, young heiress who eventually changes her ways after receiving a fatal diagnosis, does what she can with the material here, but the story is exceptionally melodramatic and threadbare. George Brent plays her incompetent doctor who is unable to remove the tumor, then outright lies to Bette about her prognosis, and unethically falls in love and marries his patient. Humphrey Bogart also has a completely unnecessary role as a horse trainer.  Best Picture Nomination

Oscar Nominations: Best Picture; Best Actress in a Leading Role; Best Music, Original Score

Three Comrades (1938)

I’ve found Margaret Sullavan unexpectedly appealing ever since seeing The Shop Around the Corner. Here she is a sick woman in post-World War I Germany who becomes the shared love interest of long-time friends Robert Young, Robert Taylor, and Franchot Tone. There is a lot of chemistry amongst the foursome and I really appreciate that time is spent showing the relationships in every possible pairing. It’s unusual to see a portrayal of Germany between the wars filmed during that time period. While the politics are only lightly touched, there is a sense that the touch is an honest one for at least some part of the population.   Romance

Oscar Nomination: Best Actress in a Leading Role

Double Wedding (1937)

I really enjoyed how screwbally this Powell-Loy pairing was. Myrna Loy is a no-nonsense businesswoman whose plans are disrupted when her sister, whose fiancĂ© has been all picked out, is encouraged to pursue a career in acting by bohemian William Powell. As expected, hijinks and romance follow suit. Seeing Powell’s trailer house and its set decoration is a delight, especially when the entire cast makes their way into the vehicle for the big day, reminiscent of the stateroom scene from A Night at the Opera.  Romance

More About Nostradamus (1941)/Penny Wisdom (1937)

Here I go again combining two short film Oscar nominations together. I highly doubt either of these would ever be considered for nominations in modern times, but we also don’t get to see shorts like these to watch before each movie anymore either. More About Nostradamus is a sequel of sorts to 1938’s Nostradamus focusing on various predictions that could be construed as relating to World War II, making it an odd propaganda piece as well.

Penny Wisdom is a Pete Smith-narrated short about a stupid housewife (this is reiterated multiple times) who is a failure at cooking dinner, so help in the form of advice columnist Penny Prudence saves the day. There are at least a couple of interesting home economics tips thrown in for good measure.

Oscar Nomination: Best Short Subject, One-reel (More About Nostradamus)

Oscar Win: Best Short Subject, Color (Penny Wisdom)

Scroll to Top