Category: Animated

Bubbling Over (1934)/Guard Dog (2004)

Bubbling Over is a short with an all Black cast featuring the incredible talent of Ethel Waters. Waters is a poor woman saddled with the laziest husband alive along with his incredibly lazy family. It mostly serves as an artifact of its time, but it does have a few entertaining musical numbers. Waters wasn’t in nearly enough films so I’ve been checking out those I can find.

Guard Dog is a Bill Plympton cartoon that attempts to explain why a neurotic dog barks so much. Even with the dog protagonist, I’m not much of a fan of Plympton’s animation style. The short plot does tie up nicely that at least produces a bit of a chuckle in the end.

Oscar Nomination: Best Short Film, Animated (Guard Dog)

Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer (1964) – Rewatch

It’s not surprising that Rudolph is one of the earliest Rankin-Bass productions as it misses a lot of the notes that makes me love their later works. First off, its runtime feels way too long for an adaptation of a simple song. To pad it, a whole lot of characters and adventures get added unnecessarily. Secondly, some of the ‘good’ guys really come off as jerks. It’s hard to be an endearing Christmas special when your Santa is a grumpy bigot. The messaging as a whole is a bit suspect as the normies seem to only accept the misfits when they need something from them. As always, I do enjoy the stop-motion animation. It’s as appealing as any of their other specials. Also despite there being too many of them, I like a whole lot of the added characters from Hermie to Bumble to Yukon to the various Misfit Toys. Any of their adventures could have easily sustained an engaging 20 minute special on their own.  Animal  Holiday

Shaun the Sheep: The Flight Before Christmas (2021)

During a farmhouse raid, Timmy the little sheep is lost in a gift box, first finding himself under the tree at the community bazaar and then in the hands of little girl who believes he is her Christmas present. The rest of the flock with Bitzer in tow must rescue Timmy before it’s too late. You can’t go wrong with Shaun the Sheep and there’s special hilarity with the little girl’s parents who are so obsessed with their technology and internet presence that they don’t even notice a flock of sheep invading their house. It somehow manages to feel modern and quaintly timeless simultaneously.  Animal  Holiday

How the Grinch Stole Christmas (1966) – Rewatch

The classic Dr. Seuss television special continues to both provide a fine representation of his work and also inspirational Christmas fodder. The misanthropic Grinch’s only understanding of Christmas is by watching the Whovian celebrations each year, thinking that it’s all about the things that encompass Christmas traditions instead of the internal shared feelings that the holiday brings to the Whos. On a large, new television, the fluorescent colors are almost lurid in their boldness, but the simple classic animation and memorable songs remain indelibly ingrained in the mind. As a related aside, I shout mental expletives to all who were involved in the 2000 live-action abomination, but more importantly to all those who think it’s a good idea to ‘arrest’ the Grinch during community holiday celebrations, clearly people who never actually read or watched the tale nor understand the concept of a redemption arch.   Musical  Holiday

Snowy Day/If You Give a Mouse a Christmas Cookie (2016) – Rewatch

I pair these two because I’ve watched them together every year since they first appeared on Prime. They are both delightful adaptations of well-known children’s picture books. While they are both enjoyable, I love Snowy Day more. It perfectly encapsulates Ezra Keats’s beautiful illustrations and urban setting with an excellent voice cast that includes Regina King, Angela Bassett, and Laurence Fishburne. As a bonus, it contains a new Boyz II Men song that serves as a soundtrack through the entire short. If You Give a Mouse a Christmas Cookie focuses solely on the animal characters, really stretching the story of them trying to fix the school holiday pageant that they almost ruined. It’s a cute and inoffensive diversion that also captures its book inspiration well.  Holiday

Frosty the Snowman (1969) – Rewatch

Somehow this classic Christmas short manages to flesh out an entire special out of the well known song. By adding in a couple of extra named characters not mentioned in the lyrics, it presents a more thorough story of Frosty’s struggle between having fun with his new friends and melting away forever. Though it remains a bit questionable for a young girl to just hop on a freight train to the North Pole, the story is a mild diversion that doesn’t overstay its welcome, at least not until it decided to inspire multiple sequels, each with lessening returns.   Holiday

A Charlie Brown Christmas (1965) – Rewatch

The plot is well known in this holiday classic: Charlie Brown is fed up with the materialism he finds all around him at Christmas time and agrees to direct the school’s pageant. The animation is classic and colorful. The emotions are relatable as everyone probably feels a bit like Charlie Brown each year at Christmas time. I love the unadulterated joy the entire group possesses when they’d rather dance than rehearse and the beautiful little tree in both its original and spruced up forms. I probably take a bit off of my rating for Linus’s Bible quoting in the middle. It seems to only serve as unnecessary religiosity while neither answering Charlie Brown’s question nor resolving his ennui.   Holiday

How Murray Saved Christmas (2014) – Rewatch

Murray is the owner of a diner in Stinky Cigars, a secret town populated by a greatest hits of holiday superstars. When Santa Claus is knocked out on Christmas Eve, Murray is recruited to deliver all the presents. It’s a completely irreverent, but amusing, tale done in classic animation style with an adult sensibility commonly found in prime time cartoons. It’s got a great voice cast, including Sean Hayes, Jason Alexander, and Dennis Haysbert, some silly fun songs, and is narrated in almost Seussian rhyme. The fairly short film is probably not for everyone, but can provide a reprieve from standard Christmas-time fare.  Holiday

Arthur Christmas (2011) – Rewatch

Arthur, voiced by James McAvoy, is the younger, under-appreciated son of Jim Broadbent’s Santa Claus. On the night that this iteration of Santa is expected to hand the sleigh over to his eldest son, the delivery of a single child’s gift is missed. Arthur and Grand-Santa set out on an adventure to rectify the mistake, using old school technology. An original tale which cleverly explains some of the Santa Claus mythology using modern twists and amusing little touches, the film is appealingly animated in classic Aardman style with a top notch vocal cast.   Holiday

Mickey’s Christmas Carol (1983) – Rewatch

Another contender for my favorite version of A Christmas Carol that maintains its Victorian setting, this one could possibly push aside the competition just because of its much more appealing runtime. Like the Muppet version, the Disney characters are almost perfectly assigned to each of their roles. Though Goofy is a somewhat weird choice for Marley, the ghosts are great this time around. But really, this story doesn’t need more than 30 minutes to tell and I love classic Disney animation.  Holiday

Scroll to Top