Category: Best Acting

Ulee’s Gold (1997)

In this slow-burning character study, Peter Fonda is Ulee, a widowed Vietnam vet who spends his days working the family bee hives and cares for his two grandchildren whose father is serving time for a bank robbery. When his son’s accomplices surface looking for money that was hidden after the robbery, Ulee is pried out of the shell he has kept himself hidden in and must deal with the risk these men pose to his family. The film relies solely on Fonda’s performance and it’s a strong one. It is indeed slow to get going, but is satisfying in the end.

Oscar Nomination: Best Actor in a Leading Role

It’s a Wonderful Life (1946) – Rewatch

When I was young, I avoided this film. It was one my father loved and I disregarded it as a crusty black and white film, though I did always enjoy the swimming pool scene. In high school, it was shown during a lesson about suicide and I was oddly taken with it to the point where it has become one of my favorites. The well-known and often-copied tale of a desperate but much-loved man who is shown what life would have been like if he had never existed is perhaps a perfect film. It’s well-acted, manages a delicate balance between its drama and comedy, and gorgeously incorporates a real sense of self in its Bedford Falls location. The pairing of James Stewart’s George Bailey hero with Lionel Barrymore’s villainous Potter is unmatched in cinema.   Best Picture Nomination  Holiday

Oscar Nominations: Best Picture; Best Actor in a Leading Role; Best Director; Best Sound, Recording; Best Film Editing

Miracle on 34th Street (1947) – Rewatch

This is such the seminal telling of the story that I can’t watch any of the other versions despite trying. Edmund Gwenn IS Santa Claus, come to spread Christmas and belief to Macy’s executive Maureen O’Hara, her young daughter Natalie Wood, and New York City at large. I’ve been watching this film all my life at Christmastime and the sentimentality, nostalgia, and desire to believe in the Christmas spirit have never wavered upon each viewing. The one thing that has changed in recent viewings is my joy at seeing the US postal service being a hero in the film. There’s a bittersweetness that gets added when thinking of how it has been gutted in recent years.   Best Picture Nomination   Holiday

Oscar Wins: Best Actor in a Supporting Role; Best Writing, Original Story; Best Writing, Screenplay

Oscar Nomination: Best Picture

Throw Momma From the Train (1987)

In this take on Strangers on a Train, Billy Crystal is a novelist who suffers from writer’s block after his ex-wife Kate Mulgrew received acclaim from a story she allegedly stole from him. He thus takes a job teaching at a community college where he meets quirky Danny DeVito who proposes that he’ll kill Billy’s ex-wife if Billy kills his overbearing mother Anne Ramsey. It’s an entertaining dark comedy with good chemistry between the two leads and Ramsey giving an especially solid performance in her supporting role.

Oscar Nomination: Best Actress in a Supporting Role

The Prince of Tides (1991)

As far as psychiatric ethics go, this film is an abomination. After his twin sister’s latest suicide attempt, Nick Nolte travels from South Carolina to New York to meet with her psychiatrist, Barbra Streisand. There under the guise of ‘helping’ his sister’s recovery, Streisand holds meetings that essentially become therapy sessions with Nolte and later starts up an extramarital affair with him. Their relationship is mind boggling on its own and then when the big twist is revealed, the whole plot flies off the handle. The film is beautifully shot, particularly the Carolina scenes, and in all of her scenes, Streisand is always cast in gorgeous light.

Oscar Nominations: Best Picture; Best Actor in a Leading Role; Best Actress in a Supporting Role; Best Writing, Screenplay Based on Material Previously Produced or Published; Best Cinematography; Best Art Direction-Set Decoration; Best Music, Original Score

A Special Day (1977)

During Hitler’s 1938 visit to Italy, a tired and overworked mother of six stays at home while the rest of her family goes to the rally. Through a series of circumstances, she ends up spending the day with one of the few other people who skipped the event, her persecuted gay neighbor. The story, told in gorgeous sepia tones, is of two lonely individuals finding solace with each other even for a short while. Sophia Loren and Marcello Mastroianni always have incredible chemistry and it matters not at all here when they aren’t meant to be romantically attached.

Oscar Nominations: Best Actor in a Leading Role; Best Foreign Language Film

The Bridges of Madison County (1995)

I remember the summer this was such a hit with middle aged, particularly white, women. Being firmly ensconced in those categories now, it seemed like a good time to check it out. It mostly doesn’t work for me. The parts with the adult children are drawn out and overall unnecessary, not helped by the fact that the two characters are quite dislikable. Clint Eastwood as the love interest here is a bit far-fetched and I kept imagining many other actors in the role. Similarly, while she brings her usual quality to her role, I didn’t quite believe Meryl Streep’s portrayal as an Italian immigrant though the melancholy and resignation she experienced as an Iowan housewife did come across. Overall there wasn’t a lot of chemistry between the two and the pairing was hurt more from that than the actors as individual characters. The setting is attractive and feels evocative of Iowa in the late summer, though the featured bridge isn’t the most inspirational structure.  Romance

Oscar Nominated: Best Actress in a Leading Role

The Eyes of Tammy Faye (2021)

Early in this film, Andrew Garfield’s Jim Bakker is at bible college, arguing in front of class regarding the meaning of various bible passages. Through the flirtatious glances cast between him and Jessica Chastain’s Tammy Faye seated in the audience, one of the worst concepts of modern day Christianity, prosperity gospel, is seemingly born. In her later life, Tammy Faye seemed to be a sweet, simple-minded, but relatively harmless, follower of Christ. Chastain’s portrayal maintains this, casting Tammy Faye as a naïve but loyal servant of the lord who couldn’t help but be caught up in the whirlwind of materialism and grifting, all in the glory of god. It’s only at moments when her beliefs and the life she lives is questioned that the mask that is literally tattooed on her face seems to crack. Similarly, Jim Bakker in current times comes across as nothing more than a narcissistic charlatan. Garfield’s slimy portrayal does him no favors. Together these two performances, along with support from the likes of Cherry Jones and Vincent D’Onofrio, elevates this film while laying out all the brash, misguided, brightly-colored glory of the Bakkers’ ministry and early televangelism at large.

Oscar Wins: Best Achievement in Makeup and Hairstyling; Best Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role

This Sporting Life (1963)

Richard Harris is a brutish, ambitious coal miner who is given a place on a local rugby team after impressing the team’s owner with his aggression. He’s an unlikable lout who assaults opposing players and attempts to rape his landlady. At the same time, no one treats him as anything more than a goon and a payday. I had a hard time relating to or finding interest in the hyper masculinity of the main character and the world he inhabits. It is obvious that Harris put much into the character, believably encompassing his roughness and belligerence.  Sports

Oscar Nominations: Best Actor in a Leading Role; Best Actress in a Leading Role

The Age of Innocence (1993)

In upper-class 1870s New York, Daniel Day-Lewis is engaged to marry Winona Ryder when her attractive cousin, played by Michelle Pfeiffer, comes to town after her own marriage falls apart. Daniel sees in the newcomer an appealing break from the constrains of society. He believes he’s cleverer and smarter than those around him, but he is no match for high society and their prescribed ways. It’s an appealing period piece with lavish sets and costuming. The story and the acting within is compelling. Though I found the romantic chemistry a bit lacking, it held my interest to mild twist of an ending.

Oscar Win: Best Costume Design

Oscar Nominations: Best Actress in a Supporting Role; Best Writing, Screenplay Based on Material Previously Produced or Published; Best Art Direction-Set Decoration; Best Music, Original Score

Scroll to Top