Category: Best Acting

Sometimes a Great Notion (1971)

Paul Newman and his father, Henry Fonda, run a family-owned lumber company in Oregon. When the rest of their town’s loggers go on strike, they make the choice to ignore the union and continue their attempts at fulfilling their contracts, no matter the cost. Things get even more complicated when college-educated, half-brother Michael Sarrazin shows back up at the family compound. There is a lot of conflict that propels the movie, both in and out of the home. The Oregon forests and rivers are filmed in stunning blues and greens and the film is sometimes at its best just showing their men at work, but what will never leave me is the most horrifying death scene I’ve ever seen in a movie. It continues to haunt me when I think about it.

Oscar Nominations: Best Actor in a Supporting Role; Best Music, Original Song

My Favorite Year (1982)

Mark-Linn Baker is a comedy writer on a variety show who is tasked with making sure the next guest, Peter O’Toole, gets to the rehearsals and the show airing sober and on time. It’s very loosely based on Mel Brooks’s experience working on Your Show of Shows with Peter O’Toole’s character being inspired by Errol Flynn. It’s tone is a bit all over, never deciding if it’s completely heart felt, slapstick, dramedy, or somewhere in between all of those. While most of the cast stick with the comedy, O’Toole manages to act through all the tones and makes for a great Flynn facsimile while also being his own character.

Oscar Nomination: Best Actor in a Leading Role

Women in Love (1969)

These very late 1960s films kill me whenever it feels like everyone was doing all the drugs and they were just trying to one-up each other with the surreal weirdness. Glenda Jackson and Jennie Linden are somewhat bohemian sisters and teachers in a coal-mining in 1920s England. Both of them become attracted to and attract the attention of two bachelors, Oliver Reed and Alan Bates. The lives of the foursome twine around each other, with the men also experiencing a connection together. There are discussions about and actions taken with regards to love and sex and commitment. Of the four characters, I most enjoyed Jennie Linden’s performance (perhaps that is telling in a pop psychology way) and find it unfortunate that there doesn’t seem to be much in her filmography to recommend itself.

Oscar Win: Best Actress in a Leading Role

Oscar Nominations: Best Director; Best Writing, Screenplay Based on Material from Another Medium; Best Cinematography

National Velvet (1944)

Elizabeth Taylor’s star quality might never have shown as much as it did as a twelve year old in this tale of the horsiest horse girl who ever did live. The smittenness of her character for The Pie oozes out of her every action, a puppy love that is portrayed better than any teen romance on film. Even Mickey Rooney’s haminess as a horse trainer can’t detract from Liz’s performance. Though sadly other family characters are either wasted, such as Angela Lansbury as the oldest sister, or annoyingly unnecessary, Jackie Jenkins’s little brother, the relationship between Liz and Anne Revere as her mother has some incredibly beautiful moments as the two bond over finding a love and purpose in life even at an unexpected age. As someone who never really interacted or understood horse girls, the tale still drew me in with its beautiful fake countryside and feel-good, family-friendliness.   Sports

Oscar Wins: Best Actress in a Supporting Role; Best Film Editing

Oscar Nominations: Best Director; Best Cinematography, Color; Best Art Direction-Interior Decoration, Color

Baby Doll (1956)

Drunken cotton gin owner Karl Malden had promised Carroll Baker’s now deceased father that he would not consummate their marriage until her 20th birthday. On the eve of that fateful day, the future of Malden’s cotton gin has depleted while Baker’s sexuality is burgeoning. Into this disturbance appears Eli Wallach, a sexier, somewhat younger, more successful, Sicilian American competitor. It’s a very sultry movie, both in its Mississippi location and the desires burning at the surface for all three characters. Malden’s character is out-matched completely by the other two, even if it takes him until the end before he fully realizes it.

Oscar Nominations: Best Actress in a Leading Role; Best Actress in a Supporting Role; Best Writing, Best Screenplay – Adapted; Best Cinematography, Black-and-White

Richard III (1955)

I’m glad I had watched the 1995 film version of the play fairly recently because it was less of a struggle to get through this one being familiarized with the narrative. I’m also really glad that Olivier’s Hamlet was black and white, because the colors in this are really distracting. I expect beautifully detailed castle interiors and instead get bare, cheap-looking sound stages. The costumes are garishly colored and the wigs are ridiculous. Both might be more faithful to a stage production, but film can do better. I much preferred the scenes filmed naturally in the outdoors toward the end. Olivier’s Richard is pretty good. It’s hard not to when he’s a master Shakespearean, but still found Ian McKellen’s superior for gross Machiavellian sliminess.

Oscar Nomination: Best Actor in a Leading Role

The Story of Louis Pasteur (1936)

A little hyperbolic to say, but this movie should be shown in all schools these days. While questionable in the actual portrayal of Louis Pasteur and the events of his life, it does illustrate the importance of science, being open to having preconceived notions challenged, and vaccinations. It’s hard to get passed the idea that washing hands and boiling instruments would be a questionable to the field of medicine. I’m glad I watched this so soon after Scarface because the comparison really shows Paul Muni’s skills as an actor.  Best Picture Nomination

Oscar Wins: Best Actor in a Leading Role; Best Writing, Original Story; Best Writing, Screenplay

Oscar Nomination: Best Picture

Cleopatra (1963)

It’s no surprise that this brought on the end of the Golden Age of Hollywood. Everything about it is overblown: the sets, the cast, the costumes, the run-time, everything. With two parts split between Cleopatra’s relationships with Julius Caesar and Mark Antony, the story just goes on and on. Edited down to an hour or two shorter and it might have held my attention better. Elizabeth Taylor is truly a beautiful woman, but she was terribly miscast in the role of Cleopatra. She lacks gravitas, cunningness, and sexiness. There’s at least the feeling of building an alliance between Taylor and Rex Harrison’s Caesar; the relationship between Richard Burton’s Mark Antony is lackluster. There must have been some love flames between them in production, but they are not seen on screen. Obviously there was no expense sparred in the visuals. Cleopatra’s arrival in Rome is a live-action version of Aladdin’s Prince Ali scene. Despite that money spent in costumes (there is one ridiculous scene where without hesitation Taylor changes between three different outfits and Burton between two), many of Taylor’s look like the same exact style just in an array of candy colors. But I did love the sets. They are lavish and beautiful, truly sights to behold. There are so many little details to be seen: wigs, clothing racks, and umpteen baths. It’s also great to see the various cast in smaller roles: Hume Cronyn, Roddy McDowell, Martin Landau and even Carroll O’Connor as a Senator.  Best Picture Nomination

Oscar Wins: Best Cinematography, Color; Best Art Direction-Set Decoration, Color; Best Costume Design, Color; Best Effects, Special Visual Effects

Oscar Nominations: Best Picture; Best Actor in a Leading Role; Best Sound; Best Film Editing; Best Music, Score – Substantially Original

Farewell, My Lovely (1975)

I had forgotten that this was based on the same story as Murder My Sweet until about halfway through though it definitely explained why it felt so familiar. As with the other film, this film noir about Moose Malloy who after being released from prison hires Philip Marlowe to find his old girlfriend Velma has a few too many moving parts that makes it unnecessarily convoluted. Robert Mitchum makes a good Marlowe. At his age, he brings a grizzled, cynical world-weariness to the character, though that makes him a poor match for Charlotte Rampling’s charms. I also find the 1970s realism less well-suited for the story.  Noir

Oscar Nomination: Best Actress in a Supporting Role

Detective Story (1951)

A surprisingly dark look at a day in a 1950s police precinct, Kirk Douglas leads the cast as an angry detective who has yet dealt with the psychological damage caused by his criminal father, seeing things and people as either all good or all bad. The cases start out fairly light, shoplifters and petty robberies, but the main story involving an illegal abortionist quickly brings the narrative and all those connected to it into a downward spiral of destruction. The acting is solid, but everyone is overshadowed by the brutish nature of Douglas’s character.  Noir

Oscar Nominations: Best Actress in a Leading Role; Best Actress in a Supporting Role; Best Director; Best Writing, Screenplay

Scroll to Top