Category: Oscar Nominee

Comes a Horseman (1978)

Jane Fonda is a single woman doing all she can to keep her family’s ranch despite the land hungry machinations of Jason Robards. She’s helped on her fool’s errand by Richard Farnsworth and James Caan. Fonda looks appropriately unglamorous and gritty as a woman more or less on her own on the frontier, but the whole affair is a bit dull and uninvolving. The film is supposedly set toward the end of World War II, but other than the vehicles and a mention of post-war declining beef prices, there is nothing that makes this distinctly of that era over any other in the history of the American West.   Western

Oscar Nomination: Best Actor in a Supporting Role

The Cotton Club (1984)

I watched the Encore version of this. In trying to figure out the differences between it and the original, I looked at Roger Ebert’s review and it seems that, while still flawed, Encore is the better version. The original apparently removed many scenes with Black characters, which not only removes a lot of the talent shown, but also changes the focus away from the titular Club and solely on to the trite gangster story anchored by Richard Gere. The scenes in the club are the best part of the film, filled with the all Black talent of singers and dancers, including the fabulous Gregory Hines and his brother Maurice, and the glamour of the all white clientele. There are many other great performances, both large (Bob Hoskins and Fred Gwynne’s bromance) and small (Gwen Verdon, Tom Waits, Lawrence Fishburne), and the film is beautiful too look at. It all just gets dragged down by almost all the bits involving Gere’s character.  Musical

Oscar Nominations: Best Art Direction-Set Decoration; Best Film Editing

Fat City (1972)

True 70s gritty realism here, Stacy Keach is a washed up boxer in Stockton, California who encounters young Jeff Bridges at a local Y and encourages him to take up the gloves. The film follows these two over a period of time as their boxing careers, and love lives, take opposite trajectories. Stockton is shown as a grim, depressing locale where the only jobs available are farm labor and the only entertainment is the local bar. In his early 30s, Keach somehow is as beat down as the city where he lives, whereas the only a handful of years younger Bridges is his exact opposite. Thus ends my unplanned mini Jeff Bridges marathon.   Sports

Oscar nomination: Best Actress in a Supporting Role

Feeling Through (2019)

Much better than my previous Oscar short watch, Feeling Through tells the story of a homeless young man who encounters a DeafBlind man needing assistance one night. I appreciate how the streets visually change from when the young man is safe with friends to when he’s alone trying to find a place to stay. Those struggles are nicely juxtaposed to the struggle the DeafBlind man experiences trying to get himself home safely.

Oscar Nomination: Best Live Action Short Film

Real Steel (2011)

Fitting in well with the fighting films I’ve been watching, Real Steel is a cross between the Rocky and Transformers series, imagining 2020 as a year where robots have replaced humans in the sport of boxing. If only that were the biggest concern of 2020. Hugh Jackman is a former human boxer and wannabe robot champion owner who reunites with his estranged son after the son’s mom dies. Are orphaned children foisted on estranged parents in real life as often as they are in movies? The movie is super predictable. The son is of course a precocious wannabe owner himself and there’s a shoehorned love interest played by Evangeline Lilly. The only surprise was that I kept expecting a turn where the son wasn’t even his as Jackman was taken aback multiple times when he was told the kid was older than he expected.

Oscar Nomination: Best Achievement in Visual Effects

Curfew (2012)

While I haven’t yet seen any of other nominees from the year, I have no idea why this would be nominated for an Oscar, let alone win. A suicidal man reconnects with his family when he’s asked by his sister to watch his precocious nine-year-old niece for a few hours. It’s decently made (acting not bad, visually appropriately gritty, etc.) but the story comes across as a misguided PSA for a suicide helpline.

Oscar Win: Best Short Film, Live Action

Thunderbolt and Lightfoot (1974)

After losing the spoils of their previous score, Clint Eastwood’s Thunderbolt is compelled to perform one more heist with his former gang. Jeff Bridges’s young hoodlum, Lightfoot, is brought along for the ride, despite the misgivings of pretty much everyone else. Most of the movie is a buddy flick with Eastwood and Bridges romping around Montana together, powered along by Jeff’s grating laughter. They have quite a bit of chemistry, though Bridges good-naturedly does most of the work while Clint provides plenty of scowls.

Oscar Nomination: Best Actor in a Supporting Role

Lacombe, Lucien (1974)

Like my previous Louis Malle watch, Murmur of the Heart, the main character of this film is a teenager who seems to think the world owes him whatever he wants. After being turned down by the French Resistance, Lucien joins up with the German police where his interest in a Jewish woman shines a spotlight onto her and her family. Lucien is rough and his motivations are often indiscernible. The film does provide a look into a population not often shown in World War II films, non-heroic Nazi supporters in countries invaded by Germany.

Oscar Nomination: Best Foreign Language Film

The Good Shepherd (2006)

I might have seen this film about the birth of CIA counter-intelligence, but it is so dull that I barely remember it enough to write this review. Matt Damon is fine as the main character, whom the film follows from his college days being recruited by the CIA to his own son having the same experience. Most of the rest of the cast, filled with well-known names who drop relatively quickly in and out of the story, also are fine in their roles. Angelina Jolie is the exception, horribly miscast as Damon’s long-suffering wife. The story jumps back and forth between different time periods quickly and without much clarity, aside from poor aging makeup that somehow Damon managed to avoid.

Oscar Nomination: Best Achievement in Art Direction

Michael Collins (1996)

I don’t know a whole lot about the fight for Irish independence, nor how accurate this film is to the life of the revolutionary leader, but even if he might have been too old to portray the titular character, Liam Neeson brings quite the Irish spirit to the role. He joined by Aidan Quinn form such a bromance that Julia Roberts, as their mutual love interest, fades into the background, a supremely uncommon feat. There is plenty of intrigue and tension in the battle for independence and Alan Rickman is great as always in the main antagonist (aside from the British) role. The beautiful Irish countryside and soundtrack do their best to encourage patriotic fervor to even casual viewers.

Oscar Nominations: Best Cinematography; Best Music, Original Dramatic Score

Scroll to Top